RankingsUpdated August 2026

The 23 Best-Rated Nursing Homes in Sarasota, FL (2026)

Every CMS-certified nursing home in Sarasota, FL, independently ranked by health inspection scores, staffing levels, and penalty history — never paid placement. See how our ranking method works

23Nursing Homes in Sarasota
3.0/5
-0.2 vs state avgState avg: 3.20Sarasota Avg Rating
$95K+$24K vs state avgState avg: $71KAvg Fine (When Penalized)
Neighborhood
Sort by
Filters activeReset filters
1No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center

Corporation

★★★★★5 out of 5 stars5.0ExcellentCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection5.0
  • Staffing5.0
  • Quality Measures4.0
45 BedsInspected Jun 2025

Above Florida avg of 3.2

1959 N Honore AveSarasota, FL 34235

(941) 379-3553

View Facility
2No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Glenridge On Palmer Ranch Inc.

Corporation

★★★★★5 out of 5 stars5.0ExcellentCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection5.0
  • Staffing5.0
  • Quality Measures5.0
61 Beds

Above Florida avg of 3.2

7333 Scotland WaySarasota, FL 34238

(941) 552-3603

View Facility
3No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Pines Of Sarasota

Corporation

★★★★★5 out of 5 stars5.0ExcellentCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection5.0
  • Staffing4.0
  • Quality Measures5.0
171 BedsInspected May 2024

Above Florida avg of 3.2

1501 N Orange AveSarasota, FL 34236

(941) 365-0250

View Facility
4No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Plymouth Harbor Incorporated

Corporation

★★★★★5 out of 5 stars5.0ExcellentCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection4.0
  • Staffing5.0
  • Quality Measures4.0
56 BedsInspected Dec 2025

Above Florida avg of 3.2

700 John Ringling BlvdSarasota, FL 34236

(941) 365-2600

View Facility
5No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Sarasota Memorial Nursing & Rehabilitation Center

Corporation

★★★★★5 out of 5 stars5.0ExcellentCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection4.0
  • Staffing5.0
  • Quality Measures5.0
120 BedsInspected Mar 2025

Above Florida avg of 3.2

5640 Rand BlvdSarasota, FL 34238

(941) 917-4950

View Facility
6No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Sunnyside Nursing Home

Faith-based

★★★★★5 out of 5 stars5.0ExcellentCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection4.0
  • Staffing5.0
  • Quality Measures5.0
60 BedsInspected May 2025

Above Florida avg of 3.2

5201 Bahia Vista StreetSarasota, FL 34232

(941) 371-2729

View Facility
7No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Inn At Sarasota Bay Club

Corporation

★★★★☆4 out of 5 stars4.0Above AverageCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection3.0
  • Staffing5.0
  • Quality Measures3.0
44 BedsInspected Aug 2024

Above Florida avg of 3.2

1303 North Tamiami TrailSarasota, FL 34236

(941) 953-6949

View Facility
8No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Life Care Center Of Sarasota

Sole proprietorship

★★★★☆4 out of 5 stars4.0Above AverageCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection3.0
  • Staffing3.0
  • Quality Measures5.0
120 BedsInspected Sep 2025

Above Florida avg of 3.2

8104 Tuttle AveSarasota, FL 34243

(941) 360-6411

View Facility
9No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Bay Village Of Sarasota

Corporation

★★☆☆☆2 out of 5 stars2.0Below AverageCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection3.0
  • Staffing1.0
  • Quality Measures4.0
95 BedsInspected Apr 2024

Below Florida avg of 3.2

8400 Vamo RoadSarasota, FL 34231

(941) 966-5611

View Facility
10No Penalties

Nursing HomeSarasota, FL

Creekside Health And Rehabilitation Center

Corporation

★★☆☆☆2 out of 5 stars2.0Below AverageCMS Overall
  • Health Inspection2.0
  • Staffing3.0
  • Quality Measures4.0
178 BedsInspected Aug 2025

Below Florida avg of 3.2

5511 Swift RoadSarasota, FL 34231

(941) 921-7462

View Facility

City report

Care landscape in Sarasota

How Sarasota compares with the rest of Florida on three signals families ask about most.

  • Population 65+36.5%

    About 52% higher than the state average of 24.0%.

    Census ACS 2023 (ZIP-weighted)
  • Nurse staff turnover44.5%

    A little higher than the state average of 42.5%.

    CMS PBJ 2024
  • Cognitive disability11.6%

    About 19% lower than the state average of 14.3%.

    CDC PLACES (ZIP-weighted)

See full demographics & care economics for Sarasota →

FAQ

Questions families ask about this page

How many facilities were evaluated in Sarasota, FL?

This page evaluates 23 eligible nursing homes in Sarasota, FL and shows the top 23.

How are these rankings calculated?

Facilities are ranked by CMS overall rating first. Ties are broken by fewer penalties, then health inspection rating, then staffing rating.

Should I rely on these rankings alone?

No. Use the rankings to narrow the field, then review facility profiles, confirm details directly with the provider, and get professional guidance for the care decision.

Was this rankings helpful?